Jewelry Cleaning Myths That Could Be Ruining Your Pieces

We all want our jewelry to shine like new—but when it comes to cleaning your favorite pieces, not everything you’ve heard is true. In fact, some popular jewelry cleaning myths could be doing more harm than good. Before you reach for toothpaste or toss your gems in boiling water, read on.

Here are some of the most common myths about jewelry cleaning—and the truth that will help you protect your treasures.

🔮 Myth #1: Toothpaste Is a Great Jewelry Cleaner

Truth: Toothpaste is far too abrasive for most metals and gemstones. It can scratch soft stones like opals, turquoise, or pearls, and even dull the finish on gold and silver.

Better Option: Use a gentle jewelry-specific cleaner or a mix of warm water and mild dish soap with a soft brush.

🔥 Myth #2: Boiling Water Will Deep Clean Your Jewelry

Truth: Boiling water may help clean some solid gold or platinum items, but it can crack gemstones (like opals or emeralds), loosen glue, or warp delicate settings. It’s especially risky for jewelry with mixed materials or older, heirloom pieces.

Better Option: Stick to warm—not boiling—water and avoid heat altogether for delicate or antique pieces.

Click on Lovelace Diamond Necklace – Caratly to buy the product.

🧽 Myth #3: Baking Soda Is Safe for Everything

Truth: Baking soda is another abrasive cleaner that can scratch soft stones and wear down gold or silver over time. While it's a classic cleaning agent for household use, it’s not always jewelry-friendly.

Better Option: Use a soft polishing cloth for silver tarnish or consult a jeweler for safe alternatives.

💦 Myth #4: You Don’t Need to Clean Jewelry Often

Truth: Everyday wear leads to buildup from lotions, sweat, and dirt. Neglecting your jewelry can dull its sparkle and even cause long-term wear if grime accumulates under stones or in clasps.

Better Option: Clean your jewelry gently every few weeks at home, and have it professionally cleaned and inspected once or twice a year.

Click on Bumble Diamond Earring – Caratly to buy the product.

🧼 Myth #5: Soap and Water Are Always Safe

Truth: Mild dish soap and water are safe for many pieces—but not all. Some stones (like pearls, opals, and amber) are porous and can absorb liquids, weakening them over time.

Better Option: For these delicate materials, skip soaking. Instead, gently wipe with a soft, damp cloth and let air dry.

Conclusion: Protect the Sparkle by Knowing the Facts

Jewelry is often sentimental, valuable, and sometimes irreplaceable. The wrong cleaning method can turn a beloved piece into a cautionary tale. By separating myth from truth, you can keep your pieces safe, sparkling, and beautiful for years to come.

When in doubt—ask a jeweler. It’s always worth the peace of mind.